Persons as a Commodity
Many years ago, when I was still a university student studying Economics, I took an upper-level Public Finance course and came across the concept of “value of a human life”. At first blush, this seems sacrilegious, that one could try to put a value on human life. However, I found the concept intriguing.
The idea is that if each person’s life was truly of infinite value, we would treat it as such, and the fact is that we don’t. People drive too fast, take harmful drugs, smoke, and many other things which reveal that they don’t value their own life having infinite value. This includes those of us who profess Christ.
There are many ways that economists estimate the value of a human life, but back when I attended school, I recall that estimates of a human life were in the $250,000 - $1,000,000 range; today most values used by government agencies for things such as cost-benefit analysis put the value of your and my life at between $7.5 million and $10 million. Regardless of the value, we can be priced in the marketplace; we are a commodity.
An example of where this leads is never more obvious than in abortion. Many in our society place no value on the life of an unborn child, and you could argue that they actually consider the value to be negative, given that the child is considered to “intrude” upon the mother’s life. The child’s existence actually reduces the value of the mother’s life. The child is a commodity: something that was nonsaleable and did not (and should not) have a price, but is now saleable at some price.
That cost may be income lost through not having a full-time job because of child rearing, the general inconvenience brought on by having to take care of an infant, or loss of reputation in one’s community. As a result, you can eliminate this cost (i.e., price) by eliminating the source – the unborn child.
If you want another commodification of an unborn infant’s life, consider that an abortion costs anywhere from between $500 to $2,000+, depending on the type, gestational age, and other factors. Considering that a child can be bought and sold for that amount, he/she is not regarded as being worth much; certainly not the $7.5-$10 million estimate we noted, above.
We see a similar result with the practice of human trafficking. Worldwide, estimates of the value of a trafficked person average about $13,600, albeit with estimates ranging from $4,000 to as much as $50,000. Aside from the obvious issue of commodification of life, it is extremely sad that the value of a trafficked victim is hundreds of times lower than that of you or me. The examples of commodification go on and on, with prostitution, beauty, pornography, etc.
In the latest insult to our society’s perceived value of human life, our friends at Netflix® are airing a new series: He’s Expecting – When a successful ad executive who's got it all figured out becomes pregnant, he's forced to confront social inequities he'd never considered before. I can’t make this stuff up if I tried.
Netflix® obviously has its own rather transparent agenda and continues to show us that, just when we think it can stoop no lower, it rolls out yet more vapid content. That notwithstanding, a baby is once again shown to be a means to an end. A commodity to be used as an expedient route to push the LGBTQ agenda (and at the same time, insult mothers everywhere).
So, after all this, why does it matter so much if people are regarded as commodities? Very simply, because the core of who we are is eternal. As C.S. Lewis put it so eloquently:
It is a serious thing to live in a society of possible gods and goddesses, to remember that the dullest most uninteresting person you can talk to may one day be a creature which, if you saw it now, you would be strongly tempted to worship, or else a horror and a corruption such as you now meet, if at all, only in a nightmare. All day long we are, in some degree helping each other to one or the other of these destinations. It is in the light of these overwhelming possibilities, it is with the awe and the circumspection proper to them, that we should conduct all of our dealings with one another, all friendships, all loves, all play, all politics. There are no ordinary people. You have never talked to a mere mortal. Nations, cultures, arts, civilizations - these are mortal, and their life is to ours as the life of a gnat. But it is immortals whom we joke with, work with, marry, snub, and exploit - immortal horrors or everlasting splendors.
We may decide to smoke, drink too much, never see a doctor, or other ill-advised things. Humans do stupid things, there is no doubt, however the eternal lives within us. That’s why we are not worth $6,000 or $10 million. We may be a commodity in society’s eyes, but in the eyes of Him who gave us value, we are most definitely not a commodity. We are priceless.
Education in North Dakota
I thought that title might grab your attention. Why? It’s simple. Anything that involves the shaping and upbringing of our children (and grandchildren) is of paramount importance to us, and not just to us, but also to those opposed to our beliefs. We all know that if we impart our values to future generations, we lock in a legacy that will live for decades. As the oft quoted poem title goes, “The Hand That Rocks the Cradle Is the Hand That Rules the World.”
Do you think North Dakota’s education system is generally good or bad, when compared to other states? Let’s look at some ratings, recognizing their limitations and associated caveats. U.S. News & World Report has the North Dakota education system right in the middle of the pack at #25 (combined score of #16 for higher education and #34 for pre K‑12), based on educational attainment, graduation rates, college debt and tuition costs, enrollment in pre-K, standardized test scores, and the public high school graduation rate. USA Today puts us at #15, based on indicators such as high school graduation rate, public school spending, 8th grade NAEP testing, percentage of bachelor’s degrees, and median incomes. World Population Review ranks ND at #20 (combined score of #5 for higher education and #35 for K‑12), using 33 different metrics.
So what can we make of all this? These and similar sources put North Dakota higher education rankings in the upper third of the list, and k-12 in the second third. Collectively, they put the North Dakota education system somewhere slightly above the middle of the pack – not great, not terrible. Would we like to be higher on the lists? Sure, but there are as many suggested solutions to this issue as there are North Dakotans. Nevertheless, we can all agree that we must continue to improve our educational system as best we can.
However, Christian parenting and educating our children is much more than getting the best ranking. We have a biblical mandate to, “Train up a child in the way he should go; even when he is old he will not depart from it.” (Proverbs 22:6). The Bible is full of exhortations to parents that they should teach their children morals and virtues that are based on biblical principles.
Make no mistake, this is not limited to simply at home. There are three places where most of our children’s instruction happens: home, church, and school. Parents are responsible for the instruction their children receive in all three places and more. You are responsible. Not the church, not the school, not summer camp, not a mentor, not the latest celebrity. You are intended to have both the responsibility and control.
Our state’s educational system is perhaps not ranked as high as we’d like, but education in North Dakota has an ever-growing more serious problem, similar to other states. I’m talking about a problem of values. Thankfully, most school districts have their compasses pointed in the right direction here in North Dakota, but the insidious creep of moral relativism and political expediency has already been at work in our state.
Grand Forks School District #1 has a policy that allows school officials to not tell parents that their child identifies as transgender. It also allows for children of the opposite biological sex to enter restrooms and locker rooms if identifying as transgender. The West Fargo School District has a very similar policy on these issues, with some modifications. NDSU was taken to task by our legislators, with the prospect of losing a portion of state funding, for their active financial support of Planned Parenthood’s educational activities in our state. UND recently tried to adopt a hate speech policy that would penalize those who did not capitulate to the LGBTQ social agenda. Unfortunately, I’m pretty sure there are more examples.
Why am I calling all these institutions out? It’s about accountability to your values. These are institutions you financially support. If North Dakotans don’t have an issue with the values underlying these actions, then let’s plow forward. However, if we do have a problem, we need to do something about them. They are not going away, my friends.
What can you do? Attend school board meetings, run for your local school board, contact institutions of higher education when they step over the line, make sure your lawmakers are aware of what is happening, and similar involvement. You might note that the NDSU and UND examples I gave earlier were both resolved in a manner that upheld your family values. It can be done!
A friend and I were talking recently about these types of educational challenges in our state, and he summarized our ideal response perfectly. He said, “We are called to be vigilant”. He’s absolutely right. The educational future of our children and our state depend on your and my vigilance.
Marriage: What's the Point?
This June, it will be 35 years since Ruth and I said “I do” at a beautiful church in Washington State. It was something we had looked forward to for a number of years and we were thrilled to see it finally happen. My father officiated, which was very special, and he eventually got to those famous words we all know so well, “…for better or worse, for richer or poorer, in sickness and in health…”. It was a wonderful ceremony, and it kicked off decades of marriage, in which my wife has been very long-suffering and put up with me and my nonsense.
Here's the thing: we had no idea what we were agreeing to. We understood that we had taken a solemn vow before God and that we promised to keep it, “until death us do part”. That we got. But the better/worse, richer/poorer and sickness/health part we had no way to comprehend. We were in our early twenties, healthy as could be, and had our whole exciting lives ahead of us, full of promise and hope.
We were hopelessly in love and infatuated with the other person. You remember. You would watch the phone, hoping and praying it would ring. Your heart skipped a beat the first time you held hands in a movie theater. Or that long-awaited first kiss. The insanity of it all; that lovesick feeling. There is nothing else like it.
Time marches along and that infatuation grows into a deeper love over the years. You work through the good times and tough times. You see each other at your best and at your worst. Nobody knows you better. Finances get debated, children are born, dogs adopted, houses purchased, and jobs changed. Now you are starting to get a better idea of what that vow meant, but through it all, you find that your best friend has become much more than you ever imagined.
So, am I just being nostalgic? To be completely honest, yes, I am being somewhat nostalgic, but it’s good to do that occasionally. Like when the dog barfs on the floor, the kids are chasing each other with markers, and you find out your car needs a new alternator – all at the same time. However, there’s more to my point.
The better/worse, richer/poorer and sickness/health depended on one thing that June day three decades ago: the vow. It was a vow taken before God, and if there is one thing that is almost universally understood, it is that you don’t break a vow taken before God. Even if we didn’t understand what lay ahead of us, we knew we just made a solemn vow. In the final analysis, we “got it” that day, after all.
That vow has kept us going, when life would have otherwise pulled us apart. Ruth and I will never claim to be close to a perfect couple, but it’s that foundation on faith and God’s direction for our lives which sustains our marriage and our family.
God instituted the very first family in the Garden of Eden, and He preserves and protects the family with a jealous love. When others seek to break down marriage or the family, or make a mockery of them with secular interpretations, it is ultimately doomed to fail. Without God in the center of the marriage, it all starts to come apart.
That’s why North Dakota Family Alliance does what we do: protect the biblical institutions of marriage and the family. I truly hope our children and eventual grandchildren will see that God is the center of our marriage, and that we fought to keep it that way, from our living room to the halls of Bismarck.
I know I just scored a lot of husband points for this email, but that was not the purpose. It was to remind all of us about why biblical marriage and the basis for our families are so critical. That said, it never hurts to bank a few husband points for when I do my next foolish thing.
What is Your Purpose?
The two most important days in your life are the day you were born
and the day you find out why. – Attributed to Mark Twain
I love this quote. It boils everything in our human existence down to one simple sentence. It’s certainly consistent with biblical values. We are given life by our Creator, upon which all else depends. It precedes all the choices we make – it is the root of who we are.
Our purpose on this earth is the second implied question. As humans, we seek meaning and try to understand the purpose for our lives, and fulfilling this need is central not only to who we are in relation to the rest of humanity, but who we are in the face of the God who made us as well. However, as much as I like this quote, I would add a third important day. The day you discover who controls your life.
Look at the first part of the quote. Clearly, we were not in control of our birth; most would suggest that if anyone was in control, it was our parents. However, our parents did not in some amazing way confer life upon us – they simply provided the building blocks for life. Something or someone else was in control of creating our life and allowing us to be born. If being born was truly one of the two most important days of your life, then it follows that you would want to know who made this day happen and was in control of it.
The second part of the quote is similar. Why would someone want to know the reason they were created unless they could act on it? Let’s say that you discover you were created to play Wordle for the rest of your life, although I truly wouldn’t wish this on anyone. Once you “discover” that Wordle is your life’s purpose, what happens? You find out everything you can about the game, you devote years studying the logic behind possible moves, and you spend day and night playing the game.
Did you notice which word appears most often in that last sentence? You. It suggests that once your purpose is discovered, it’s on you to make the most of it. You need to work and realize your potential and fulfill your life’s mission. You need to work on becoming the world’s best Wordle player. It’s up to you. You are in control.
I would suggest that knowing who controls your life answers both implied questions in the quote. Once you know who controls your life, you can determine who put you together as a person and who determines your life purpose. If nobody/nothing is in control of your life, then you were a collection of cells that, in some highly improbable manner, formed a human and somehow “became living”. It then follows that your life purpose can be defined by you. You are in control.
On the other hand, if someone made you and has a purpose for your life, it becomes a very different story. There is the crux of the issue.
As a Christian, I believe I was created by God and my purpose on this earth is to glorify Him. But notice that answering this question does not say how I should best glorify God. That is revealed to us by the Holy Spirit and our inclinations, genetic traits, talents, etc. that were hard coded at our creation.
Those of us at North Dakota Family Alliance do policy work supporting and advancing biblical principles. That is our purpose. I would hazard a guess that doing policy work is not your purpose in life. We glorify God by doing this work, but you may glorify God by homeschooling your children, working at your office, or perhaps harvesting your crops. However, since our purpose is policy work, we do it with all the tools and resources we can to achieve what He wills for our lives. We take it seriously and know you depend on us to defend your biblical values. Thank you for your faithful support in fulfilling this purpose.
Finding out who created you and what your purpose is can become a lifelong journey for some. I don’t know how you arrived at the point of knowing God controls your life, but it is the answer to almost every question you may have. That doesn’t mean life will be easy or always make sense, but you thankfully have a path to follow, which is more than many people.
Today, rejoice that you know your purpose. The future of your life may not be apparent all the time, but the path He has chosen is what you need to walk. When you are living in God’s will, nothing can match that feeling. Enjoy the journey; He’s got you.
What is in Your Heart?
What is in your heart? Let me take a guess. Primary is your love for faith, family, and freedom. It’s what gives you definition and meaning, and it’s what North Dakota Family Alliance fights for on your behalf every day of the year. You’re aware of all the work that was accomplished in past legislative sessions and the many wins God bestowed upon all of us. I’m here to tell you that those are wins for faith, family, and freedom.
I’m sure you’ve heard the adage attributed to Pastor Billy Graham, “Give me five minutes with a person's checkbook, and I will tell you where their heart is.” If what truly matters most to you is faith, family, and freedom, you should support organizations that represent those values. North Dakota Family Alliance does just that.
You always have the opportunity to help underwrite our work by going to our website and donating, but Giving Hearts Day is almost here and represents a unique opportunity to financially support our organization. As the name implies, it’s all about giving from the heart. This year, Giving Hearts Day is this Thursday, Feb. 10, and I’m happy to report that North Dakota Family Alliance will be a full participant.
One reason many people give on this day is that donations are matched dollar-for-dollar, and the good news is that we have once again raised matching dollars, thanks to generous donations by ministry partners. As a result, all gifts over $10 will be DOUBLED, up to our match threshold.
It’s very easy to give to NDFA on Thursday: just click this link and you’ll go right to our donation page. It’s that simple. Giving Hearts Day only lasts for 24 hours, from 12:00 am through midnight on February 10, but did you know that you can also schedule gifts to NDFA ahead of time! You can click right now and donate, and then on Feb 10, the gift is transferred to us at NDFA! And no worries, the match will still apply to all these scheduled gifts as well.
We’re very excited to be participating in Giving Hearts Day. When your heart is filled with love of faith, family, and freedom and you give accordingly, you are making a difference. Giving to our organization will allow us to continue to stand with you and help advance these values here in North Dakota.
Thank you in advance for your participation. Together, we can make a difference!